Chapter 5 — Trigonometric Functions of Real Numbers
5.6 - Close: Epistemology, History and Scientific Applications
§1. From the chord to the ratio: two thousand years before Euler
Section titled “§1. From the chord to the ratio: two thousand years before Euler”This chapter defined and as the coordinates of a point that travels around a circle, for an argument that is an arc length —a real number, without units—. No civilization that developed trigonometry before the eighteenth century thought in those terms, and it is worth going over, if only briefly, what they thought instead.
Hipparchus of Nicaea, around the year 150 B.C., constructed the first known trigonometric table: not of sines, but of chords —for each central angle, the length of the chord that this angle subtends in a circle of fixed radius—. Three centuries later, Claudius Ptolemy systematizes and extends that table in the Almagest (c. 150 A.D.), the astronomical work that would dominate Western and Islamic astronomy for more than a thousand years; his trigonometry remains, in essence, a table of chords associated with a particular radius, not an abstract function.
The step from the chord to something more like the modern sine occurs in India: Aryabhata, in the Aryabhatiya (499 A.D.), works with the jya —half-chord—, which is, geometrically, what is today called sine, although still tied to a triangle and to a specific radius, not to a unit circle nor to an abstract numerical argument. Mathematicians of the medieval Islamic world —Al-Battani in the ninth century, Abu al-Wafa in the tenth— refine these ideas, compute ever more precise tables, and introduce the tangent and the cotangent as ratios in their own right, not as derived quotients. At no moment of these two thousand years, however, does “sine of ” mean what it meant in this chapter: in all cases, the input is an angle —a geometric figure, measured in degrees or in some subdivision of the circle—, never a real number that simply measures a distance traveled.
§2. Euler’s turn toward the function
Section titled “§2. Euler’s turn toward the function”The decisive change occurs, once again, in the same book that this chapter already cited indirectly and that Chapter 4 cited several times: the Introductio in analysin infinitorum of Leonhard Euler, of 1748. Euler is, as the historiography of mathematics acknowledges, the first to treat sine and cosine systematically as functions —in the modern sense, numerical input and output— of an argument that measures, in essence, arc length on a circle of radius , not an angle in a triangle with sides of arbitrary length. It is, exactly, the same conceptual movement that this chapter formalized with in §5.2: to take the unit circle as a fixed stage, and let a real number —not an angle, not a triangle— determine the point.
That this turn took two thousand years to occur, from Hipparchus to Euler, is not a minor detail of the history of mathematics: it is the same kind of gap that separated the informal use of irrational , attributed to the same Euler, from its rigorous foundation —mentioned in the close of §4.1— and that separated Napier’s tables of logarithms from their complete justification —§4.4 §6—. In the three cases, practical utility and effective computation preceded, by centuries, the question of why the object used had to exist and be unique.
§3. Why Euler’s turn was still not enough
Section titled “§3. Why Euler’s turn was still not enough”It is worth being precise about what Euler achieved and what he did not. Treating sine as a function of a real number was a genuine conceptual leap, but Euler himself did not have —because it did not yet exist— a rigorous definition of what the “arc length” that this number measures is. His geometric intuition, supported by the infinitesimal calculus that he himself helped to develop, was operationally powerful but was not grounded with the rigor that Cauchy and Weierstrass would demand a century later —the same gap, once again, that the close of §4.7 documented for the exponential—.
This chapter closed that specific gap for trigonometry in a way that neither Hipparchus nor Ptolemy nor Euler himself had available: constructing arc length from scratch, with inscribed and circumscribed polygons —§5.1— and the completeness axiom, exactly the same tool that in Chapter 4 grounded . That the trigonometry of this book arrives at the same six functions that Hipparchus tabulated more than two thousand years ago, by a path that none of his predecessors could travel, is the best evidence that the mathematical object is older and more robust than any of its successive foundations.
§4. The trigonometric functions in contemporary science
Section titled “§4. The trigonometric functions in contemporary science”The reason why this chapter devoted so much effort to constructing as a function of a real number —and not as a ratio between sides of a triangle— is, precisely, that contemporary science needs that version: almost no wave phenomenon involves triangles.
Waves and oscillations. Sound is a periodic variation of pressure in the air; light, an oscillation of electric and magnetic fields; the alternating current of an electrical grid, a voltage that follows, with very high approximation, the form —exactly the general form of §5.5 §5, with playing the role of —. In no case is there a physical triangle involved: there is a quantity that oscillates in time, and and are, simply, the vocabulary that describes that oscillation with precision.
Fourier analysis. Joseph Fourier, in 1822, showed that practically any periodic function —not only those of the simple form of §5.5— can be written as a sum, generally infinite, of sines and cosines of different frequencies. That technique —analyzing a complex signal by decomposing it into its sinusoidal components— is today the basis of digital signal processing, audio and image compression, and a good part of telecommunications engineering. This book cannot develop that theory —it demands convergence of infinite series of functions, terrain that exceeds precalculus just as it exceeds the derivative—, but it is worth naming it: it is, in a certain sense, the culmination of Euler’s decision to treat sine as a function.
Navigation and positioning. GPS determines a position by triangulating distances to several satellites; that triangulation is, at its core, trigonometry in the most classical sense —that of Hipparchus and Ptolemy—, applied with a precision that neither of them could have imagined.
§5. Close: the question that remains open
Section titled “§5. Close: the question that remains open”§5.5 already anticipated, in its own close, the question that this entire chapter left pending: how fast changes at each instant, and why that rate turns out to be —the fact that makes these functions the natural tool to describe, not only positions that oscillate, but velocities and accelerations that oscillate with them—. It is, once again, the same frontier that closed Chapter 4: the question is formulated with all the precision that this book allows, the object —, , both constructed without any concession from the completeness of — exists and is completely characterized, and the only thing missing is the instrument —the derivative— that Calculus I will provide.
That the trigonometry of this book has arrived here by a path that took two thousand years to be found for the first time, and almost three hundred more to be grounded with the rigor demanded here from the first page, is not an anecdotal datum with which to close the chapter: it is the same lesson that in Chapter 3 and in Chapter 4 left —that the utility of a mathematical object and the certainty of its existence are two distinct conquests, that rarely arrive together, and that this book, chapter after chapter, set out not to separate.
Copyright © 2026 Carlos Dagorret — Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)