Chapter 1 — Fundamental Concepts
1.5 — Equations
To solve an equation is to ask for which values a statement stops being a possibility and becomes a fact.
An equation is an equality between two expressions in which at least one variable appears. Unlike an identity, such as those of §1.3, it is in general not true for every value of the variable, but only for some, or for none. Each value that makes it true is a solution, and the set of all of them is the solution set. To solve the equation is to find that set in full: it is not enough to find some solutions; we must make sure that none has been left out and that nothing has slipped in that is not one.
With the factoring of §1.3 and the rational expressions of §1.4, this section organizes the methods of solution according to the type of expression. The thread that ties them together is a single question: when does an algebraic step preserve the solution set, and when does it not? From the answer comes a phenomenon that appears here for the first time, the extraneous solution: a number that solves an equation obtained along the way, but not the original one.
§1. Equivalent equations and linear equations
Section titled “§1. Equivalent equations and linear equations”An equation in has the form , where and are algebraic expressions. It only makes sense to ask whether a number is a solution when both sides are defined at ; the set of those numbers is the domain of the equation, in the same sense as in §1.4. Two equations are equivalent when they have the same solution set. Solving an equation consists, almost always, in replacing it by an equivalent and simpler one, until we reach one whose solution set is plain to see. The two basic steps that guarantee equivalence are the following.
Proposition. Let be an equation with domain , and let be an expression defined on all of . Then, for :
(i) is a solution of if and only if it is a solution of ;
(ii) if moreover , then is a solution of if and only if it is a solution of .
Proof. Fix and write , and , which are real numbers. For (i): if , adding the same number to both sides gives ; conversely, if , adding to both sides gives . For (ii): if , then ; conversely, if and , multiplying by the inverse of §1.1 gives .
The key lies in the “conversely”. Each of these steps can be undone by another step of the same kind, and that is why it neither gains nor loses solutions. Multiplying by an expression that vanishes at some point, on the other hand, can make new solutions appear: the passage from to fails when . This is the origin of all the extraneous solutions in this section.
A linear equation in is one that, by means of those steps, can be brought to the form , with . If , we add and multiply by , and we obtain the equivalent equation : there is a unique solution. If , the equation reduces to , a statement in which no longer appears. It is true for every if , and then the solution set is , or false for every if , and then the solution set is empty, . This case is not an oddity: it reminds us that solving does not always produce a single number.
§2. Quadratic equations
Section titled “§2. Quadratic equations”A quadratic equation has the form , with . The heavy lifting was already done in §1.3, which factored the trinomial by completing the square. Only one ingredient is missing here, the one that lets us pass from a zero product to its factors.
Zero product property. For , if and only if or .
One of the two implications is the lemma of §1.3: if , one of the factors is zero. The other comes from §1.1: if , then , and likewise if . This property, and not a habit of manipulation, is what allows us to pass from to ” or ”. The proof of the lemma uses the fact that every nonzero real has an inverse; in a number system without that guarantee, the property could fail. With a product of three or more factors it is applied several times: the product is zero if and only if one of the factors is.
Proposition. Let with , and let be the discriminant.
(i) If , the equation has exactly two solutions,
(ii) If , it has exactly one solution, .
(iii) If , it has no real solutions.
Proof. If , §1.3 gives for every . By the zero product property, and since , the right-hand side equals if and only if or . Moreover , which is nonzero if and zero if . This proves (i) and (ii), because if both formulas give . If , in the proof in §1.3 we saw that for every real , and that is (iii).
The formula that sums up (i) and (ii) is written with a single symbol, , where indicates that we take the sign once and the sign once. For example, in we have and , so that . Factoring and using the formula are not two different methods but the same result read in two ways: when the factorization is visible at a glance, it is faster; when it is not, the formula always finds it.
§3. Equations with radicals
Section titled “§3. Equations with radicals”An equation with radicals is one in which the variable appears inside a root, as in . The usual method is to isolate the radical and raise both sides to the index of the root to eliminate it. But squaring is not one of the safe steps of §1: it cannot be undone, because the square does not distinguish a number from its opposite. Indeed, by the difference of squares of §1.3 and the zero product property,
The symbol reads “if and only if”: each statement implies the next one and also the previous one. Squaring the equality produces a weaker statement, which also holds when . Extraneous solutions come from there, and the following proposition says exactly which ones they are.
Proposition. Let and be algebraic expressions. A real number is a solution of if and only if and .
Proof. Suppose that . A square root is, by definition (§1.2), a nonnegative number, so ; and squaring, . Conversely, suppose that and . Then , because it is a square, and is defined. Moreover, is a nonnegative number whose square is , and by the uniqueness of the root proved in §1.2, .
The proposition says that every solution of the original equation solves the squared equation, , but that the latter may have extra solutions: those with . Those are the extraneous solutions. They are not computational errors, but the necessary consequence of a step that loses information. The practical conclusion is that every solution obtained by squaring must be checked in the original equation, or else by verifying that . The same happens with any even index. When there is more than one radical and we must square twice, the safest course is to check each candidate in the starting equation.
Example. Let us solve . Squaring, , that is, , which factors as . The candidates are and . Here . For , , and indeed . For , : it is an extraneous solution, because and not . The solution set is .
§4. Equations with rational expressions
Section titled “§4. Equations with rational expressions”When the variable appears in a denominator, the usual procedure is to multiply both sides by the least common denominator of §1.4. The fractions disappear and the equation reduces to a linear or quadratic one. Is this a safe step? By part (ii) of the proposition of §1, it is on the whole domain of the original equation, because there the least common denominator does not vanish. Outside that domain the proposition says nothing. The equation without fractions may have solutions at the excluded values, and those are not solutions of the original equation, which is not even defined there.
From this comes the method. First we determine the domain of the original equation. Then we multiply by the least common denominator and solve the resulting equation. Finally, we keep only the solutions that belong to the domain. It is the same care that simplification required in §1.4: the expression without denominators does not remember which values were forbidden.
Example. Let us solve
Since , the domain excludes and , and the least common denominator is . Multiplying both sides by it leaves , that is, , whose only solution is . But is not in the domain. The original equation has no solutions: its solution set is .
The opposite phenomenon also occurs. In , the domain excludes . Multiplying by we obtain , that is, , which holds for every real. Discarding the excluded value, the solution set is , and not all of as the equation without denominators would suggest.
With the methods of solution now established, the chapter is ready for their most direct application: translating problems described in words into the language of equations, the task of the next section.
Copyright © 2026 Carlos Dagorret — Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)